Thursday, November 8, 2007

FREE BOB BEALE - CHRISTIAN TAX EDUCATOR

Subj:Bob Beale
Date:11/8/2007 12:53:28 P.M. Central Standard Time
From:

Sharon4Anderson HAVE A GREAT VETERANS DAY 12NOV07 PLEASE VISIT http://cpljimanderson.blogspot.com/ When the State,County,City "takes" your HOMESTEAD away from you, YOU may be another Beale QUESTIONS: How can the State Attorney General look the other way, Take our Homes by Illegal FEES, Ratified on Theft,Trespass,Treason, based on False DSI Testimony.?

To:RKupchella@kare11.co
CC:dboxmeyer@comcast.net
Right-click picture(s) to display picture options

iNDIndicted Aaron Foster Murder _NO BAIL

Court Uniformity ?Bob Beale-Educator-Tax Evader??

This Blogger verily believes that Bob Beale is Title 26 501(c)3 Educator
not Tax Evader, YOU BE THE JUDGE'S
kare11.com :: KARE 11 TV - Beale Talks: Once a millionaire, he became a pauper fighting the system on the run
Beale Talks: Once a millionaire, he became a pauper fighting the system on the run



More Interviews

Sixty-four-year-old Robert Beale is a fugitive from Minnesota. He failed to show up for a federal trial on tax evasion charges more than 14 months ago.

He was a man who seemingly had it all. Married with four sons, he was starting and selling businesses - earning himself tens of millions of dollars in the process. He had two lavish homes - one in North Oaks, Minnesota and another in Naples, Florida. He had a private plane.
FREE BOB BEALE
Neat Article "but for" is Bob Beale a Tax Educator or Tax Evader?
Affiant has copied many of his legal briefs re: attached
Sharon Anderson exposing major corruption in St.Paul City Hall
primarily in the Budget etc. http://sharon4council.blogspot.com/ phasing to
Beale is the Real Hero for Christianity.
PS I sincerely believe Beale and Me are the only non-lawyers "prose" to have ECF and Pacer Accts.
to have Electronic Case Filing no to file electronically you have to be of good moral character.
Go Bob
Beale must be given a PC in Jail to do his legal work ie: Jail House Lawyer
Since I'm trying to have MN AG indict the city of St. Paul for Election/Ethics/Environment Corrupt Acts
my PC has an illegal firewall had to resotre 3 times, problem opening 8.0 Adobe?


5NOV07
LEGAL NOTICE: TO STATE DFL- AG LORI SWANSON
GOOD LUCK TO ALL CANDIDATES IN THE STATE OF M
5NOV07
LEGAL NOTICE: TO STATE DFL- AG LORI SWANSON
GOOD LUCK TO ALL CANDIDATES IN THE STATE OF MINNESOTA
WIN LOSE OR DRAW, WE THE PEOPLE MUST CONTINUE TO
HAVE ACCOUNTABILITY FROM SCHOOL BOARDS, MAKING $900MONTHLY
PARTTIME COUNCIL AT $63 THOUS YRLY PLUS PARKING,INSURANCE ETC.
ELECTIONS BASED ON FRAUD, THEFT,TRESPASS,TREASON MUST BE VACATED
THEREFORE SHARON ANDERSON AND BILL DAHN HEREBY GIVES NOTICE
PURSUANT TO THE CRIMINAL CODES : TO VACATE THE CITY COUNCIL ELECTIONS
IN THEIR ENTIRETY FOR COMMERCIAL BRIBERY. ON FILE. STEALING CARS FOR
PECUNIARY GAIN OF AARON FOSTER AND POLICE IMPOUND LOT, POLICE FEDERATION
ENDORSING WITHOUT SCREENING, USING OUR TAX DOLLARS, WHEN Vacant Buildings-1,404-Sept07 90%POLICE CANNOT VOTE AND OR LIVE IN THE CITY OF ST. PAUL?
TAXACTION WITHOUT REPRESENTATIONS
http://www.ag.state.mn.us/
Elected Aitkin Co. Attorney DISBARRED? http://opinions-unpublished.blogspot.com
Monday,November 5, 2007
Lory your site is very disappointing to file complaints online: Constructive Critism would be to file in word program.
Criminal Charges of Vote Fraud in the Ward (2) City Elections based upon has been served
electronicall and otherwise on your Office without response.??
voting rights act - Google Search More about
Attorney General
Lori Swanson1400 Bremer Tower
445 Minnesota Street
St. Paul, MN 55101
corrupt practices in politics, fraud connected with elections. The term also refers to various offenses by public officials, including bribery, the sale of offices, granting of public contracts to favored firms or individuals, and granting of land or franchises in return for monetary rewards. Election fraud may consist of efforts to influence or intimidate the voter or to tamper with the official
ballot or election count. To eliminate these practices nearly all democratic nations have passed laws that attempt to safeguard the honesty of political campaigns, elections, and officials. In Great Britain the Acts of 1883 and 1918, frequently amended, define election abuses and limit political spending by or on behalf of candidates for Parliament. In the United States individual states have their own election laws, preceding federal statutes. In large cities of the United States election fraud has historically been associated with political machines (see bossism ). On the federal level, the Corrupt Practices Act of 1925, the Hatch Act of 1940, parts of the Taft-Hartley Act of 1947, and the campaign financing legislation of 1974 were attempts to limit campaign spending and the size of contributions. Requiring public disclosure and providing public funding of the presidential campaign were in response to abuses connected with secret campaign funds used in the 1972 presidential election (see Watergate affair ). Subsequently, the Senate and the House established ethics committees and codes of conduct, and required public accounting of income and campaign contributions. The Ethics Act of 1978 and the stricter Government Ethics Reform Act of 1989 bar top government officials from lobbying private corporations or other governments for specified periods after leaving office. The latter act also bars former executive branch officials, congressmen, and their staff members from trying to influence senior employees in their former branches for one year after they leave office. These reforms, however, have not prevented the proliferation of Political Action Committees, a marked increase in campaign spending, and the creative use of loopholes, such as "soft money" for party-building, with no contribution limits. The term "corrupt practices" has also been applied to businesses and labor unions, in the former case for price fixing, and in the latter for misappropriation of funds or the rigging of union elections.
(651) 296-3353
(800) 657-3787

Attorney General Lori Swanson Joins U.S. Senator Amy Klobuchar in Washington D.C. to Testify on Cell Phone Contracts Before the U.S. Senate Commerce Committee
AG Swanson testifies in support of Consumer Cell Phone Empowerment Act authored by U.S Senator Klobuchar and U.S. Senator Rockefeller
http://www.ag.state.mn.us/Consumer/PressRelease/071017AGTestifyOnCellPhone.asp Full StoryState Seal

Attorney General Lori Swanson Settles Suit Against Allianz
Under the settlement, Allianz will provide restitution to Minnesota seniors and implement more stringent suitability processes
http://www.ag.state.mn.us/Consumer/PressRelease/071008AllianzSettlement.asp Full Story

State Seal

Attorney General Swanson Files Lawsuit Against Sprint Nextel
Lawsuit alleges that company unlawfully extended contracts--without obtaining knowing consent--when customers made small changes to their phone service
http://www.ag.state.mn.us/Consumer/PressRelease/070927SprintNextel.asp Full Story

State Seal

Swanson, State AGs Settle School Bus Merger Case
Attorney General Swanson's antitrust challenge argued that the merger of the two largest school bus contractors in the nation violated federal antitrust laws. The settlement allows local school districts to assume bus depot leases and open greater competition in the bidding for school bus contracts.
http://www.ag.state.mn.us/Consumer/PressRelease/070927BusMerger.asp Full Story

State Seal

Attorney General Obtains Guilty Plea in Case Involving Living Trust Salesman http://www.ag.state.mn.us/Consumer/PressRelease/70830LivingTrustSalesman.asp Full Story

State Seal

Attorney General Swanson Files Lawsuit to Halt Foundation’s Investment Scheme
Foundation obtained “charitable” loans from citizens by promising rates of return as high as 72% on “endowment grants”
http://www.ag.state.mn.us/Consumer/PressRelease/070828AshmoreFoundation.asp Full Story

State Seal

Attorney General Lori Swanson Urges Creditors to Assist Flood Victims
http://www.ag.state.mn.us/Consumer/PressRelease/07082FloodVictims.asp Full Story

State Seal

Attorney General Swanson Files Lawsuit to Shut Down Sham Charity
Suit Alleges that ABC Humanitarian Trust Did Not Use Vehicle Donations for Charitable Purposes.
http://www.ag.state.mn.us/Consumer/PressRelease/070822ShamCharity.asp Full Story

State Seal

Attorney General Swanson Takes Action Against St. Paul Radiology Regarding its Billing Practices
Files Court Action to Compel St. Paul Radiology's Cooperation with Investigation into the Clinic's Billing and Debt Collection Practices
http://www.ag.state.mn.us/Consumer/PressRelease/0810StpaulRadiology.asp Full Story

State Seal

Attorney General Swanson Testifies before Congressional Financial Services Committee
Attorney General Swanson Testifies before United States House of Representatives Financial Services Committee on the Impact of Predatory Mortgage Lending and Foreclosures.
http://www.ag.state.mn.us/PDF/PressReleases/PredatoryMortgageLendingTestimony.pdf Full Story

State Seal

Attorney General Swanson Supports Federal Legislation to Curb Predatory Mortgage Lending
Swanson Joins Federal Legislators and Community Organizations in Washington D.C. to Announce Federal Legislation Modeled after Minnesota’s Newly-Passed Law
http://www.ag.state.mn.us/Consumer/PressRelease/0707PredatoryMortgageLending.asp Full Story

State Seal

Attorney General Swanson Testifies Before the Federal Reserve Board on Predatory Mortgage Lending
Swanson Urges Federal Reserve Board to Take Action to Curb Abusive Mortgage Lending Practices.

State Seal

Attorney General Swanson Issues Fraud Alert to Warn Minnesotans of Financial Scams
Alert Warns of Foreign Lottery Scams, Cashiers Check Scams, Advance Fee Loan Scams and Phishing Scams, Which are Advanced by New Technology
http://www.ag.state.mn.us/Consumer/PressRelease/070531FraudAlert.asp Full Story

State Seal

Attorney General Swanson Asks MySpace.com to Disclose Information on Registered Sex Offenders that it has Discovered with Profiles on its Website
Swanson requests that MySpace.com disclose profile and contact information of all MySpace.com users that the company has identified as sex offenders in the State of Minnesota and requests data on users registered as sex offenders in other states who have used Minnesota addresses in connection with the website.
http://www.ag.state.mn.us/Consumer/PressRelease/070601MySpace.asp Full Story

State Seal

AG Swanson and New York AG Cuomo Enter Settlement Agreement with Capella University Regarding Student Loan Investigation
Attorney General Lori Swanson along with New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo today announced a settlement agreement with Capella University relating to the school’s student loan referral practices.
http://www.ag.state.mn.us/Consumer/PressRelease/070515CapellaUniversity.asp Full Story

State Seal

Attorney General Swanson Files Lawsuit Against Another Annuity Insurer
Attorney General Lori Swanson today filed another lawsuit against a life insurance company for unsuitable sales of long term annuities to Minnesota senior citizens.
http://www.ag.state.mn.us/Consumer/PressRelease/0706AnnuityInsurerLawsuit.asp Full Story

State Seal

Attorney General Swanson and Minnesota Hospitals Announce Continuation of Fair Medical Billing Agreement
Attorney General Lori Swanson and the Minnesota Hospital Association announced an agreement that establishes medical billing and debt collection standards for all hospitals in Minnesota. Minnesota Hospitals have agreed not to charge uninsured patients more than they charge their largest insurance companies for the same service. The agreement also sets forth guidelines to establish more fair medical debt collection practices.
http://www.ag.state.mn.us/Consumer/PressRelease/FairMedicalBilling.asp Full Story

State Seal

Attorney General Swanson Cautions Students About Undisclosed Financial Inducements In College Loan Industry
Attorney General Lori Swanson announces a series of inquiries regarding financial inducements paid by lenders to colleges for the referral of student loans. The inquiries follow a number of reports in which colleges have acknowledged receiving 1/2 percent of the loan amount for referring students to lenders. The colleges steer the students by including the lenders on a "preferred lender" list and by advising students that the use of certain lenders will ensure a quick processing of the loan.
http://www.ag.state.mn.us/Consumer/PressRelease/0703FinancialInducements.asp Full Story Click here to view Student Loan Guide

State Seal

Attorney General Swanson files suit against American Family Legal Plan and Heritage Marketing and Insurance Services - Suit charges companies with running a “trust mill” that preys upon senior citizens

Attorney General Swanson said that American Family Legal Plan initiates a “trust mill” scheme by direct mailing to senior citizens, claiming special expertise in estate planning and promoting ways to avoid estate taxes and probate fees. Swanson said that once an agent gains entry to the home of the senior, the agent will distort and misrepresent the impact of probate fees and estate taxes, causing the senior citizen to buy a trust out of fear that their heirs will lose the estate.

Following a meeting with that agent, A.G. Swanson said that the senior then receives a short telephone call from an attorney requesting general information. Regardless of assets, marital status, existing estates plans, or likely tax or probate liability

Senior citizens are often targeted by unscrupulous salespeople who prey on senior’s f



Candidate Profile FCC Complaints - Google Search Times v. Sullvian Libel with malice - Google Search BlogItBabe2007
Candidate profile Sharon4Anderson's Legal BlogBriefs Sharon4Anderson St.Paul City Council Ward2 SA-Blogs2007
LEGAL NOTICE: /s/Sharon4Anderson@aol.com ECF_P165913Pacersa1299 telfx: 651-776-5835: Document's are based on SEC filings, current events, interviews, press releases, and knowledge gained as financial journalists, Private Attorney Generals, Candidates for Public
Office documents expressly forbids its writers from having financial interests in securities they recommend to readers, affiliated entities, employees, and agents an initial trade recommendation published on the Internet, after a direct mail publication is sent, before acting on that recommendations, and may contain errors. Investment decisions should not be based solely on theseSHARON-MN-ECF: Judges-Greylord-Libby-Guilty LUFSKY Scap129FAnokaP2697(1976) Cpl James R. Anderson USMC 11022885 Bio for Sharon Anderson , TAKING DL_AOL Journal Legal Eagle SharonAnderson 1 Journalism Ethics Blogger: 1986 Petition Jane Duchene MN Bull SharonScarrellaAndersonUSBriefs - Buzznet Sharon'sFedCases1973to2006_13pdf Anderson + Advocates http://www.sharonanderson.org/ ht
FEDERATION
ENDORSING WITHOUT SCREENING, USING OUR TAX DOLLARS, WHEN Vacant Buildings-1,404-Sept07 90%POLICE CANNOT VOTE AND OR LIVE IN THE CITY OF ST. PAUL?
TAXACTION WITHOUT REPRESENTATIONS
Sharon Ans/C
ElNovember 5, 2007
Lory your site is very disappointing to file complaints be to file in word program.
Criminal Charges of Vote Fraud in the Ward (2) City Elections based upon has been served
electronicall and otherwise on your Office without response.??
voting rights act - Google Search More about
Attorney General
Lori Swanson1400 Bremer Tower
445 Minnesota Stree
6NOV07
VOTE TODAY ,WE'VE LOST OUR TAX-PAY
GOOD LUCK TO CANDIDATES: HOWEVER SERIOUS ISSUES OF CRIMINAL CONDUCT
HAS NOT BEEN ADDRESSED BY THE ST. PAUL CITY COUNCIL AND THE MAYOR
WHISTLEBLOWERS: homegrown Sharon and Bill Federally US CODE: Title 42,TITLE 42—THE PUBLIC HEALTH AND WELFARE PRotected class by 42 USC 3631
Click here: Sharons-Voting-Rights click on pic's to show StateDFL AG Lory Swanson downMS 363AHumanRights zing High Tech for consumers
http://ademocracy.blogspot.com reliable source forensic evidence
www.sharonderson.org WATER SHUT OFF is Conspiracy to commit Murder as on files.

Saturday, November 3, 2007

Cops buying City Elections-Aaron Foster'NO BAIL

How did Barbara Winn die? 26 years later, the truth may be emerging
Prosecutor says the Maplewood woman was slain as her boyfriend assaulted her
BY MARA H. GOTTFRIED
Pioneer Press

In the room where Barbara Winn died, there were signs of a struggle - an overturned plant, a broken curling iron and a torn-up photograph of her favorite movie star.

Police found a note in Winn's dresser she had written to her boyfriend, Aaron Foster Sr.: "I will not be abused. I am tired of bruises. I am somebody and I don't have to be treated like a nobody."

Foster said he went to his mother's work the night of May 7, 1981. Winn and another girlfriend of Foster's were there, talking about how they needed to get Foster out of their lives.

An argument between Foster and Winn began and Foster's mother told him to leave.

Foster went to an Elks club. A man, who told police he had been at the club at about 10:30 p.m., said he saw Foster in the restroom, accusing another man "of possibly seeing his 'lady friend.' " Foster reportedly threatened that man with a gun.

Later, Foster said he went to a bar and met Winn. The conversation turned into an argument, Foster said.

"He said they argued about another lady," a police report stated. "As he was leaving the bar she said he should pack his things. She also threw a glass at him."

Three people later told police Foster struck Winn. The bar's owner said he heard Foster say, "If I can't have you, no one else will."

Foster said he went to Winn's home in Maplewood and began packing. Winn arrived about an hour later and the argument continued.

THE SCENE

Officers were sent to 368 Dorland Road at about 12:20 a.m. on May 8, 1981 on a "domestic" after a neighbor called about glass breaking. About a minute later, a shooting was reported.

According to Maplewood police reports from 1981 and from the Ramsey County sheriff's office investigation:

Foster met officers in front of the house and was "hysterical." He had blood on his hands "and appeared distraught and anxious."

Officers followed Foster to a bedroom and saw Winn's body on the floor.

Foster told police he was downstairs, packing. Winn was upstairs, he said. Foster said he heard a shot and went upstairs. Foster said Winn told him to get rid of the gun.

Foster said he went downstairs to call police, got frustrated with how long it was taking and broke a window. Foster said that's where the blood on his hands came from.

Then, Foster drove to a nearby 7-Eleven store, where he said he called for an ambulance again. On the way, he said he threw the gun out the car window.

Winn's three children had been in their rooms, on the same floor as their mother's room, when she was shot. Her sons, then 12 and 15, said they heard Foster and Winn fighting and then a loud noise. They went to her room and Foster was running out.

THE CASE NOW

Foster was arrested in 1981, but he wasn't charged until Thursday.

The Ramsey County sheriff's office started an investigation into Winn's death in 2006, when a St. Paul police officer questioned whether Foster should have a concealed-weapon permit because he had been a suspect in Winn's death.

Retired St. Paul Police Chief Bill Finney, a close friend of Foster's, questioned the timing of the investigation. He and Ramsey County Sheriff Bob Fletcher were in a contentious race for sheriff, which Fletcher narrowly won.

In a statement Friday, Finney said: "I've worked for and supported the criminal justice system my entire life. I believe in it and am confident the judicial process will reveal the truth so Barbara Winn's family can finally find peace."

Fletcher referred the case in August 2006 to the Ramsey County attorney's office for consideration of charges.

Some of the Ramsey County sheriff's investigators' conclusions:

-- The angle of the shot that killed Winn "seems to coincide" with Winn's and Foster's height.

-- A cut on Winn's hand and gunshot residue suggested her hand was on the gun's cylinder when it went off.

-- Foster's statements are "inconsistent" - he gave different statements about where the gun was before and after the shooting; he said Winn told him to get rid of the gun, but her children said she wasn't able to speak; he told emergency dispatchers she "shot herself" and also "she got shot."

-- Foster said he didn't assault Winn, but the autopsy and disarray in the room showed signs of a struggle - a photograph of Winn's favorite actor, Billy Dee Williams, was torn up and other items were strewn about.

Ramsey County prosecutors referred the case to their Anoka County counterparts to avoid any conflict of interest.

The Anoka County attorney's office told Winn's family two months ago they would be convening a grand jury in Ramsey County.

The grand jury had to consider the laws as they were written in 1981, said Bob Goodell, an Anoka County prosecutor. The indictment that the grand jury handed up, third-degree murder, is the equivalent of second-degree murder today, Goodell said.

If Foster is convicted, 1981 sentencing would be used: maximum penalty of 25 years in prison, though the presumptive sentence was eight years and one month, Johnson said.

During Foster's first court appearance Friday, prosecutors sought bail of $350,000.

Earl Gray, Foster's attorney, pointed out that Foster had turned himself in Thursday night after an arrest warrant was issued, has worked for the city for 15 years and didn't have a criminal record.

Ramsey County District Judge Michael Fetsch ordered a conditional release. He told Foster to stay away from Winn's children and to check in with officials by phone once a week.

Foster, a clerk in the St. Paul police impound lot, is on unpaid leave.

Asked about Foster's temperament since his indictment, Gray said, "He's all right. He's a diabetic and he's not real healthy and he's very nervous like anybody would be. It's difficult to defend yourself against charges 27 years old, let me tell you that."

Winn's family said they've waited for years for this day, but they don't want to dwell on why it took so long.

"We could point fingers, we could place blame and that's really not going to get us anywhere at this point," said Patty Bruce, Winn's sister-in-law. "The really important thing right now is that we are where we are today. We are on the right track for justice for Barbara."

Mara H. Gottfried can be reached at mgottfried@pioneerpress.com or 651-228-5262.

Twenty-six years after Winn was shot in her Maplewood home, a Ramsey County grand jury indicted Foster, a St. Paul police civilian employee, on Thursday in her murder. Foster was released from jail Friday, a day after being arrested.

The indictment against Foster, 55, for third-degree, unintentional murder doesn't offer details of the alleged crime, but it does provide some insight into the events of May 8, 1981. It says Winn died while Foster was "committing or attempting to commit a felony."

That felony was second-degree assault, Assistant Anoka County Attorney Andrew Johnson said Friday.

Foster told police in 1981 he didn't assault Winn, 35, before she died, but evidence documented in police reports suggests otherwise.

Winn had broken fingernails, a clump of hair in her hand, and bruises on her body.

Foster, through his attorney, has said he's not guilty. He told police Winn killed herself.

THE HOURS BEFORE

Maplewood police reports from 1981 and newer reports from the Ramsey County sheriff's office investigation paint a picture of what might have happened in the hours before Winn


Foster said he went to his mother's work the night of May 7, 1981. Winn and another girlfriend of Foster's were there, talking about how they needed to get Foster out of their lives.

An argument between Foster and Winn began and Foster's mother told him to leave.

Foster went to an Elks club. A man, who told police he had been at the club at about 10:30 p.m., said he saw Foster in the restroom, accusing another man "of possibly seeing his 'lady friend.' " Foster reportedly threatened that man with a gun.

Later, Foster said he went to a bar and met Winn. The conversation turned into an argument, Foster said.

"He said they argued about another lady," a police report stated. "As he was leaving the bar she said he should pack his things. She also threw a glass at him."

Three people later told police Foster struck Winn. The bar's owner said he heard Foster say, "If I can't have you, no one else will."

Foster said he went to Winn's home in Maplewood and began packing. Winn arrived about an hour later and the argument continued.

THE SCENE

Officers were sent to 368 Dorland Road at about 12:20 a.m. on May 8, 1981 on a "domestic" after a neighbor called about glass breaking. About a minute later, a shooting was reported.

According to Maplewood police reports from 1981 and from the Ramsey County sheriff's office investigation:

Foster met officers in front of the house and was "hysterical." He had blood on his hands "and appeared distraught and anxious."

Officers followed Foster to a bedroom and saw Winn's body on the floor.

Foster told police he was downstairs, packing. Winn was upstairs, he said. Foster said he heard a shot and went upstairs. Foster said Winn told him to get rid of the gun.

Foster said he went downstairs to call police, got frustrated with how long it was taking and broke a window. Foster said that's where the blood on his hands came from.

Then, Foster drove to a nearby 7-Eleven store, where he said he called for an ambulance again. On the way, he said he threw the gun out the car window.

Winn's three children had been in their rooms, on the same floor as their mother's room, when she was shot. Her sons, then 12 and 15, said they heard Foster and Winn fighting and then a loud noise. They went to her room and Foster was running out.

THE CASE NOW

Foster was arrested in 1981, but he wasn't charged until Thursday.

The Ramsey County sheriff's office started an investigation into Winn's death in 2006, when a St. Paul police officer questioned whether Foster should have a concealed-weapon permit because he had been a suspect in Winn's death.

Retired St. Paul Police Chief Bill Finney, a close friend of Foster's, questioned the timing of the investigation. He and Ramsey County Sheriff Bob Fletcher were in a contentious race for sheriff, which Fletcher narrowly won.

In a statement Friday, Finney said: "I've worked for and supported the criminal justice system my entire life. I believe in it and am confident the judicial process will reveal the truth so Barbara Winn's family can finally find peace."

Fletcher referred the case in August 2006 to the Ramsey County attorney's office for consideration of charges.

Some of the Ramsey County sheriff's investigators' conclusions:

-- The angle of the shot that killed Winn "seems to coincide" with Winn's and Foster's height.

-- A cut on Winn's hand and gunshot residue suggested her hand was on the gun's cylinder when it went off.

-- Foster's statements are "inconsistent" - he gave different statements about where the gun was before and after the shooting; he said Winn told him to get rid of the gun, but her children said she wasn't able to speak; he told emergency dispatchers she "shot herself" and also "she got shot."

-- Foster said he didn't assault Winn, but the autopsy and disarray in the room showed signs of a struggle - a photograph of Winn's favorite actor, Billy Dee Williams, was torn up and other items were strewn about.

Ramsey County prosecutors referred the case to their Anoka County counterparts to avoid any conflict of interest.

The Anoka County attorney's office told Winn's family two months ago they would be convening a grand jury in Ramsey County.

The grand jury had to consider the laws as they were written in 1981, said Bob Goodell, an Anoka County prosecutor. The indictment that the grand jury handed up, third-degree murder, is the equivalent of second-degree murder today, Goodell said.

If Foster is convicted, 1981 sentencing would be used: maximum penalty of 25 years in prison, though the presumptive sentence was eight years and one month, Johnson said.

During Foster's first court appearance Friday, prosecutors sought bail of $350,000.

Earl Gray, Foster's attorney, pointed out that Foster had turned himself in Thursday night after an arrest warrant was issued, has worked for the city for 15 years and didn't have a criminal record.

Ramsey County District Judge Michael Fetsch ordered a conditional release. He told Foster to stay away from Winn's children and to check in with officials by phone once a week.

Foster, a clerk in the St. Paul police impound lot, is on unpaid leave.

Asked about Foster's temperament since his indictment, Gray said, "He's all right. He's a diabetic and he's not real healthy and he's very nervous like anybody would be. It's difficult to defend yourself against charges 27 years old, let me tell you that."

Winn's family said they've waited for years for this day, but they don't want to dwell on why it took so long.

"We could point fingers, we could place blame and that's really not going to get us anywhere at this point," said Patty Bruce, Winn's sister-in-law. "The really important thing right now is that we are where we are today. We are on the right track for justice for Barbara."

Mara H. Gottfried can be reached at mgottfried@pioneerpress.com or 651-228-5262.